Achievable logoAchievable logo
CA Code and Ethics
Sign in
Sign up
Purchase
Textbook
Practice exams
Support
How it works
Exam catalog
Mountain with a flag at the peak
Textbook
Introduction
1. Basic insurance concepts and principles
2. The insurance marketplace
3. Required fraud training — CDI
3.1 Introduction and learning objectives
3.2 Fraud Division
3.3 Fraud Division programs
3.4 Fraud detection
3.4.1 Key tools and resources
3.4.2 Suspected insurance fraud: Agent duties
3.4.3 Legal consequences of fraud
Wrapping up
Achievable logoAchievable logo
3.4.2 Suspected insurance fraud: Agent duties
CA Code and Ethics
3. Required fraud training — CDI
3.4. Fraud detection

Suspected insurance fraud: Agent duties

5 min read
Font
Discuss
Share
Feedback

Insurance agents are often the first to notice possible fraud because they work directly with applicants and policyholders. California law and industry standards place a duty on agents to help protect the insurance marketplace by serving as an early line of defense against fraud.

Recognize red flags and fraud indicators

Agents must stay alert to warning signs of possible fraud, which may include:

  • Inconsistent or incomplete application information
  • Requests for unusually high coverage limits without justification
  • Suspicious timing of claims (e.g., immediately after a policy is issued)
  • Signs of staged accidents, faked injuries, or inflated repair estimates
  • Applicants who resist providing standard documentation

These indicators don’t prove fraud by themselves. The key is to notice patterns, use sound judgment, and follow reporting procedures when something doesn’t add up.

Where an agent reports suspected fraud

When you suspect fraud, your role is to report - not to investigate. California law gives licensed agents and brokers who are individuals (natural persons) and aren’t an insurer’s employees two reporting paths, depending on whether the application has been placed with an insurer (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.41). An insurer’s own employees follow the insurer’s procedures instead:

  • Before you place an application, if you reasonably suspect or know that it’s fraudulent, report it to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days of that determination, using the Fraud Division’s online reporting form. You can’t make the referral anonymously.
  • After an application has been placed, if you reasonably suspect or know that fraud has been committed, report it directly to the insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU).

Either way, include all relevant details and documentation, and give the SIU or CDI any papers, reports, or other evidence they ask for. The insurer has its own duty: once its SIU investigation leads it to reasonably suspect or know that fraud may have occurred or might be occurring, it must report to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days of that determination (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.4).

Document and report - Do not accuse

Agents must avoid directly accusing customers or claimants of fraud. Instead, agents should:

  • Carefully document observations and communications in writing
  • Maintain a professional, neutral tone in all reports
  • Leave the determination of fraud to the SIU and CDI investigators

You’re not acting as a fraud investigator. Your job is to spot concerns, document what you observed, and refer the matter to the proper unit. This approach helps reduce liability risk and ensures fraud concerns are handled lawfully and effectively by SIUs, CDI, and law enforcement.

Here’s a fraud red flags checklist you can use as a practical quick reference in your real-world interactions:

Fraud red flag checklist (For educational purposes - not exhaustive. Always follow company SIU and CDI reporting guidelines.)

Insurance professionals must be trained to recognize “red flags” that may indicate fraud during both the underwriting and claims stages. A single indicator doesn’t prove fraud, but several indicators together may justify closer review or a referral to the SIU.

Underwriting fraud indicators

  • Inconsistent personal or vehicle information - Mismatches between the applicant’s stated details and public records, such as incorrect VIN numbers, mismatched addresses, or false employment information, may suggest intentional misrepresentation.
  • Suspicious application patterns - Applications submitted with vague answers, frequent last-minute changes, or use of multiple addresses and phone numbers can raise concerns.
  • Prior cancellations for misrepresentation - A history of past policy cancellations due to misstatements calls for a closer look. A cancellation for nonpayment alone is not a sign of fraud.

Claims fraud indicators

  • Delays in reporting - Legitimate claims are usually reported promptly. Long delays in reporting losses may indicate the claimant is attempting to stage or exaggerate a loss.
  • History of frequent claims - A pattern of repeated claims, especially across different insurers, can point to organized fraud or abuse.
  • Suspicious documentation or photos - Altered invoices, inconsistent receipts, or staged photographs of damage are frequent fraud indicators.
  • Claims filed shortly after policy inception - A loss reported very soon after a policy is issued may suggest that the claimant never intended legitimate coverage, but instead purchased the policy to make a fraudulent claim.

Example question

Maya is a licensed property & casualty agent in California who isn’t an employee of any insurer. She placed a new auto client’s application, which had inconsistent employment information, and the insurer issued the policy. Less than a week later, the client reports a major injury claim. Maya now suspects fraud and, during a phone call, angrily accuses the client of fraud and tells him she will “personally make sure” his claim is denied. She does not document her concerns or notify the insurer’s SIU.

Did Maya handle this situation in accordance with her fraud-related duties?

(spoiler)

No. The application had already been placed and Maya isn’t an insurer’s employee, so she should have documented and reported her concerns to the insurer’s SIU and cooperated with its investigation (CIC §1872.41(b)). They should not directly accuse the client of fraud or attempt to act as the investigator or decision-maker on the claim.

Agent’s role in fraud detection

  • Agents are first line of defense; duty is to report, not investigate
  • Should never directly accuse applicants/claimants of fraud
  • Leave fraud determination to SIU and CDI investigators

Reporting procedures (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.41 / §1872.4)

  • Applies to licensed agents/brokers who are individuals and not insurer employees (insurer employees follow company procedures)
  • Before application placed: report suspected fraud to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days, via online form; cannot be anonymous
  • After application placed: report directly to insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU)
  • Must provide all relevant documentation/evidence requested
  • Insurers must also report to CDI within 60 days once SIU reasonably suspects fraud

Proper documentation practices

  • Document observations/communications in writing, maintain neutral/professional tone
  • Avoid accusatory language or acting as investigator/decision-maker
  • Reduces agent liability; ensures lawful handling by SIU/CDI/law enforcement

Underwriting fraud red flags

  • Inconsistent personal/vehicle info (wrong VIN, mismatched address, false employment)
  • Suspicious application patterns (vague answers, last-minute changes, multiple addresses/phones)
  • Prior cancellations due to misrepresentation (not nonpayment alone)

Claims fraud red flags

  • Delayed reporting of losses
  • Frequent claims history, especially across multiple insurers
  • Suspicious documentation/photos (altered invoices, staged damage)
  • Claims filed shortly after policy inception

Key principle

  • No single red flag proves fraud — pattern of indicators + sound judgment should trigger referral to SIU/CDI

Sign up for free to take 4 quiz questions on this topic

Previous
Next  | 3.4.3 Legal consequences of fraud
All rights reserved ©2016 - 2026 Achievable, Inc.

Suspected insurance fraud: Agent duties

Insurance agents are often the first to notice possible fraud because they work directly with applicants and policyholders. California law and industry standards place a duty on agents to help protect the insurance marketplace by serving as an early line of defense against fraud.

Recognize red flags and fraud indicators

Agents must stay alert to warning signs of possible fraud, which may include:

  • Inconsistent or incomplete application information
  • Requests for unusually high coverage limits without justification
  • Suspicious timing of claims (e.g., immediately after a policy is issued)
  • Signs of staged accidents, faked injuries, or inflated repair estimates
  • Applicants who resist providing standard documentation

These indicators don’t prove fraud by themselves. The key is to notice patterns, use sound judgment, and follow reporting procedures when something doesn’t add up.

Where an agent reports suspected fraud

When you suspect fraud, your role is to report - not to investigate. California law gives licensed agents and brokers who are individuals (natural persons) and aren’t an insurer’s employees two reporting paths, depending on whether the application has been placed with an insurer (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.41). An insurer’s own employees follow the insurer’s procedures instead:

  • Before you place an application, if you reasonably suspect or know that it’s fraudulent, report it to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days of that determination, using the Fraud Division’s online reporting form. You can’t make the referral anonymously.
  • After an application has been placed, if you reasonably suspect or know that fraud has been committed, report it directly to the insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU).

Either way, include all relevant details and documentation, and give the SIU or CDI any papers, reports, or other evidence they ask for. The insurer has its own duty: once its SIU investigation leads it to reasonably suspect or know that fraud may have occurred or might be occurring, it must report to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days of that determination (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.4).

Document and report - Do not accuse

Agents must avoid directly accusing customers or claimants of fraud. Instead, agents should:

  • Carefully document observations and communications in writing
  • Maintain a professional, neutral tone in all reports
  • Leave the determination of fraud to the SIU and CDI investigators

You’re not acting as a fraud investigator. Your job is to spot concerns, document what you observed, and refer the matter to the proper unit. This approach helps reduce liability risk and ensures fraud concerns are handled lawfully and effectively by SIUs, CDI, and law enforcement.

Here’s a fraud red flags checklist you can use as a practical quick reference in your real-world interactions:

Fraud red flag checklist (For educational purposes - not exhaustive. Always follow company SIU and CDI reporting guidelines.)

Insurance professionals must be trained to recognize “red flags” that may indicate fraud during both the underwriting and claims stages. A single indicator doesn’t prove fraud, but several indicators together may justify closer review or a referral to the SIU.

Underwriting fraud indicators

  • Inconsistent personal or vehicle information - Mismatches between the applicant’s stated details and public records, such as incorrect VIN numbers, mismatched addresses, or false employment information, may suggest intentional misrepresentation.
  • Suspicious application patterns - Applications submitted with vague answers, frequent last-minute changes, or use of multiple addresses and phone numbers can raise concerns.
  • Prior cancellations for misrepresentation - A history of past policy cancellations due to misstatements calls for a closer look. A cancellation for nonpayment alone is not a sign of fraud.

Claims fraud indicators

  • Delays in reporting - Legitimate claims are usually reported promptly. Long delays in reporting losses may indicate the claimant is attempting to stage or exaggerate a loss.
  • History of frequent claims - A pattern of repeated claims, especially across different insurers, can point to organized fraud or abuse.
  • Suspicious documentation or photos - Altered invoices, inconsistent receipts, or staged photographs of damage are frequent fraud indicators.
  • Claims filed shortly after policy inception - A loss reported very soon after a policy is issued may suggest that the claimant never intended legitimate coverage, but instead purchased the policy to make a fraudulent claim.

Example question

Maya is a licensed property & casualty agent in California who isn’t an employee of any insurer. She placed a new auto client’s application, which had inconsistent employment information, and the insurer issued the policy. Less than a week later, the client reports a major injury claim. Maya now suspects fraud and, during a phone call, angrily accuses the client of fraud and tells him she will “personally make sure” his claim is denied. She does not document her concerns or notify the insurer’s SIU.

Did Maya handle this situation in accordance with her fraud-related duties?

(spoiler)

No. The application had already been placed and Maya isn’t an insurer’s employee, so she should have documented and reported her concerns to the insurer’s SIU and cooperated with its investigation (CIC §1872.41(b)). They should not directly accuse the client of fraud or attempt to act as the investigator or decision-maker on the claim.

Key points

Agent’s role in fraud detection

  • Agents are first line of defense; duty is to report, not investigate
  • Should never directly accuse applicants/claimants of fraud
  • Leave fraud determination to SIU and CDI investigators

Reporting procedures (Cal. Ins. Code §1872.41 / §1872.4)

  • Applies to licensed agents/brokers who are individuals and not insurer employees (insurer employees follow company procedures)
  • Before application placed: report suspected fraud to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days, via online form; cannot be anonymous
  • After application placed: report directly to insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU)
  • Must provide all relevant documentation/evidence requested
  • Insurers must also report to CDI within 60 days once SIU reasonably suspects fraud

Proper documentation practices

  • Document observations/communications in writing, maintain neutral/professional tone
  • Avoid accusatory language or acting as investigator/decision-maker
  • Reduces agent liability; ensures lawful handling by SIU/CDI/law enforcement

Underwriting fraud red flags

  • Inconsistent personal/vehicle info (wrong VIN, mismatched address, false employment)
  • Suspicious application patterns (vague answers, last-minute changes, multiple addresses/phones)
  • Prior cancellations due to misrepresentation (not nonpayment alone)

Claims fraud red flags

  • Delayed reporting of losses
  • Frequent claims history, especially across multiple insurers
  • Suspicious documentation/photos (altered invoices, staged damage)
  • Claims filed shortly after policy inception

Key principle

  • No single red flag proves fraud — pattern of indicators + sound judgment should trigger referral to SIU/CDI

More from Fraud detection

  • Key tools and resources
  • Legal consequences of fraud