Legal consequences of fraud
Insurance fraud in California isn’t only a civil matter. It can trigger serious criminal charges and regulatory consequences. The California Insurance Code, along with the Penal Code, spells out penalties for making, helping with, or even attempting fraudulent acts connected to insurance.
Perjury and criminal penalties
- Fraud warnings and perjury: Application, coverage-change, underwriting-information, and claim forms (but not reinsurance contracts) must carry, on the form or on an endorsement separate from it, a warning that knowingly presenting false or fraudulent information is a crime (CIC §1871.2). For the theft of an insured vehicle, the insurer must also get a signed claim form warning that false representations on it subject the insured to a penalty of perjury (CIC §1871.3).
- Criminal charges:
Knowingly presenting a false or fraudulent claim, or preparing a document to support one, is a crime under Penal Code §550, whether or not the insurer ever pays.
Depending on the facts and severity of the case, it may be prosecuted as a felony or a misdemeanor. Penalties may include:
- Fines (often ranging from thousands to tens of thousands of dollars)
- Restitution (repaying the insurer for fraudulent payouts)
- Probation or imprisonment (misdemeanor up to 1 year in county jail; felony = up to several years in state prison)
False and fraudulent claims article
- Defined in the Penal Code (§§549-550) and, for workers’ compensation, CIC §1871.4:
These sections define what counts as a false or fraudulent claim and provide the framework for penalties. Fraud is broadly defined and can include:
- Staging or inflating accidents or losses
- Submitting false documentation or invoices
- Concealing material facts in claims
- Conspiring with others to commit fraud
- Application fraud is a separate crime: Knowingly making a false or fraudulent material statement to obtain or amend a policy, in any line the Department regulates, is a crime punishable by a fine, imprisonment, or both (CIC §1871.10).
- Applies to all lines of insurance: These fraud provisions aren’t limited to auto or health insurance. They also apply to life, property, casualty, workers’ compensation, and disability coverage.
- Proactive fraud prevention: The law also requires insurers to maintain anti-fraud measures: an SIU (CIC §1875.20), anti-fraud training for their staff, and fraud detection procedures (10 CCR §§2698.35 and 2698.39). Licensed agents and brokers who are individuals (natural persons) and aren’t an insurer’s employees support those programs by reporting suspected fraud (CIC §1872.41(d)): to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days after determining that an application they haven’t yet placed appears fraudulent, never anonymously, and to the insurer’s SIU after it has been placed (CIC §1872.41).
Why it matters
- Fraud drives up premiums for all California consumers.
- Fraudulent claims undermine public trust in the insurance system.
- Professionals who fail to report fraud may face regulatory scrutiny or discipline from the California Department of Insurance (CDI).
Fraud isn’t just an ethical violation - it’s a crime with potentially life-changing consequences.