Key tools and resources
Detecting fraud is a critical responsibility for insurers in California. Fraudulent claims increase costs for insurers and, over time, raise premiums for all policyholders. For that reason, California’s SIU regulations require insurers to maintain written procedures, including red flags for each line of insurance, that their staff use to detect suspected fraud and refer it to the SIU. (10 CCR §2698.35)
Key tools and resources
Insurance Services Office (ISO)
- ISO is a nationwide information-sharing organization.
- Insurers use ISO databases to compare claims data across multiple companies.
- This helps identify suspicious patterns, such as:
- The same claimant reporting similar losses to different insurers
- Multiple claims tied to the same property or individual
Arson database
- Maintained as part of California’s anti-fraud efforts.
- Tracks information about suspicious fire losses and individuals with prior involvement in arson-related cases.
- Helps insurers and investigators identify repeat offenders and potentially fraudulent fire claims.
Internal red flags and trend analysis
- Insurers must develop their own systems to detect unusual claim activity.
Examples of red flags include:
- Claims filed soon after new coverage is purchased.
- Losses inconsistent with reported facts (e.g., stolen items with no receipts or proof of ownership).
- Frequent small claims from the same insured that fit a pattern.
Trend analysis helps insurers spot emerging fraud schemes, including patterns concentrated in specific regions or lines of business.
Fraud warning language
- California law requires the forms an insurer furnishes for applying for a policy, changing coverage, giving underwriting information that affects premium or eligibility under an existing policy, or making a claim to include a specific anti-fraud warning. The warning states that knowingly presenting false or fraudulent information to obtain or amend coverage or to make a claim is a crime.
- The warning serves two practical purposes:
- It deters fraud by clearly stating the consequences.
- It supports enforcement by putting claimants on notice.
Here’s the mandatory fraud warning statement from California Insurance Code §1871.2 (as amended effective January 1, 2024):
“Any person who knowingly presents false or fraudulent information to obtain or amend insurance coverage or to make a claim for the payment of a loss is guilty of a crime and may be subject to fines and confinement in state prison.”
- It must be printed or displayed as prominently as the rest of the form, either on the form or on an endorsement separate from it, preceded by “For your protection California law requires the following to appear on this form” or similar words.
- It applies to application forms, forms to change coverage, forms that give underwriting information affecting premium or eligibility under an existing policy, and claim forms. Reinsurance contracts are the one exception.
- Its purpose is to deter fraudulent activity by reminding everyone who completes these forms (applicants, policyholders and claimants) of the criminal consequences of false information.
- If an insurer fails to include this statement on their forms, they may face regulatory penalties under California Department of Insurance (CDI) rules.
Many other states have fraud warning requirements of their own, and the requirements and wording vary by state. Producers and insurers operating across multiple states must confirm what each state requires to avoid noncompliance.