Insurer responsibilities
California law gives insurers clear responsibilities to help detect, prevent, and report insurance fraud. These duties come from the California Insurance Code and the SIU regulations in Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations (CCR), and they’re enforced by the California Department of Insurance (CDI). The purpose is to keep insurers actively involved in protecting consumers, reducing fraud, and supporting the financial stability of the insurance marketplace.
Key requirements:
Special Investigation Unit (SIU)
- Every insurer admitted in California must maintain an SIU to investigate possible fraudulent claims (CIC §1875.20). Size and premium volume don’t matter. Only the kinds of insurer listed under “Who is left out” below fall outside the SIU regulations.
- The SIU reviews suspicious claims, identifies potential fraud, and refers suspected cases to CDI’s Fraud Division.
- An insurer may staff its SIU with its own employees or contract with others for it (CIC §1875.21), but either way it must meet the SIU regulations.
SIU annual report
- Each insurer files an SIU annual report with CDI when its certificate of authority is first issued and every year after that. After the first report, an insurer whose SIU work is done by another insurer in its holding company group may have that insurer (the primary reporting insurer) report for it (10 CCR §2698.40).
- The report identifies the insurer’s SIU staff (or the organization it contracts with), the people who communicate with the Fraud Division, and the insurer’s written procedures for detecting, investigating, and reporting suspected fraud. It also describes its anti-fraud training plan and how the SIU is staffed.
- Failing to file a complete and accurate report may result in administrative penalties.
Training of SIU staff and key personnel
- Insurers must ensure that SIU employees, claims adjusters, and other key anti-fraud personnel are properly trained in fraud detection and reporting requirements.
- Training must cover applicable California laws, fraud indicators, reporting protocols, and coordination with law enforcement.
- Regular refresher training helps keep staff current as fraud schemes change.
Cooperation with CDI investigations
- Insurers must cooperate fully with CDI investigations, including providing documents, claim files, and testimony when requested.
- Failure to cooperate can result in disciplinary action and fines.
Who is left out
- There’s no exemption for small insurers. No insurer escapes the SIU requirement because of its size, its premium volume, or the lines it writes.
- The SIU regulations’ definition of “insurer” (10 CCR §2698.30(k)) leaves out only certain kinds of insurer: reinsurers, title insurers, fraternal fire insurers, fraternal benefit societies, firemen’s, police and peace officer benefit and relief associations, grant and annuity societies, and home protection companies.
Together, these requirements make insurers a first line of defense against fraud. By requiring SIUs, annual SIU reports, staff training, and cooperation with CDI, California law supports a coordinated system that improves fraud detection, helps law enforcement, and reduces the higher premiums and market instability that can result from fraudulent claims.
Example question
Golden Coast Casualty writes a large book of auto and homeowners insurance in California. To cut costs, management proposes eliminating its in-house Special Investigation Unit (SIU) and simply letting regular claims adjusters “keep an eye out” for fraud. They do not plan to contract with any outside SIU vendor.
Is this approach compliant with California SIU requirements?
No. Every admitted insurer in California must maintain a unit or division that investigates suspected fraud, staffed by its own employees or provided by contract. It must also file an SIU annual report with CDI, train key personnel, and cooperate with CDI investigations. Adjusters who only “keep an eye out” for fraud, with no one assigned to investigate it, do not meet California’s SIU requirements.