Rescission of insurance contracts
Rescission
Rescission is the legal cancellation of an insurance contract that restores both parties to the position they were in before the contract was made. In practical terms, it’s treated as if the policy never existed. This remedy is available when a party - most often the insured - fails to meet legal duties of honesty and disclosure.
When is rescission allowed?
Under the California Insurance Code, insurers may rescind a contract in several situations:
Intentional and fraudulent omission about a warranty - CIC §338
- If the insured intentionally and fraudulently fails to tell the insurer something that proves, or tends to prove, that a warranty is false, the insurer may rescind the contract.
- This section is narrower than concealment in general: it’s about hiding the falsity of a warranty.
Example: A jewelry store’s policy warrants that a monitored burglar alarm is maintained. The owner learns the alarm service has been cancelled and deliberately keeps that from the insurer.
False material representation - CIC §359
- If an insured makes a false statement about a material fact in the application, the contract may be rescinded.
Example: Stating you are a non-smoker when you smoke a pack a day.
Violation of a material warranty or provision - CIC §447
- A warranty is a statement or promise in the policy that must be strictly true and complied with. If the insured violates a material warranty, rescission is permitted. The rule runs both ways: either party’s violation of a material warranty or other material provision lets the other party rescind.
Example: A commercial property policy requires the insured to maintain a sprinkler system, but the insured disables it.
Concealment - CIC §331
- Concealment is neglecting to communicate a fact you know and ought to communicate (CIC §330): a material fact, not covered by a warranty, that the other party has no means of finding out (CIC §332). It can be intentional or unintentional.
- CIC §331 specifically states: “Concealment, whether intentional or unintentional, entitles the injured party to rescind insurance.”
Example: Forgetting to disclose a past DUI conviction on an auto insurance application.
Key considerations
- Rescission is retroactive. The contract is void from the beginning, and both parties are released from their obligations. Typically, the insurer returns any premiums paid, and the insured gives up any right to claim benefits under the policy.
- Materiality is critical for concealment and misrepresentation. A concealed fact or false representation must be material, meaning it would have influenced the insurer’s decision to issue the policy, set the premium, or exclude certain risks (CIC §§331, 334, 359). The §338 ground is different: an intentional and fraudulent omission about a warranty’s falsity needs no separate showing of materiality.
- Fraud vs. innocent mistake. Fraud in the application, such as an intentional misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact, supports rescission. Rescission rests on what the applicant represented or concealed when applying (CIC §§331, 359): fraud in a later claim is a different matter, handled through that claim and the policy’s own conditions. Under the general rule, even an innocent (unintentional) concealment can justify rescission if it involves a material fact (CIC §331).
- Some lines limit rescission. A health insurer may rescind a health insurance policy only if it can show fraud or an intentional misrepresentation of material fact, must give at least 30 days’ notice by certified mail first, and may not rescind at all once 24 months have passed since the policy was issued (CIC §10384.17(a)-(c)). An individual life policy must become incontestable after it has been in force during the insured’s lifetime for no more than two years from its issue; a reinstated policy can be contested again for the same period, for fraud or misrepresentation material to the reinstatement (CIC §10113.5(a)).
Example questions
- An applicant for health insurance fails to disclose a diagnosis of diabetes.
Can the insurer rescind the policy?
Not if the omission was accidental. A health insurer may rescind a health insurance policy only if it can show fraud or an intentional misrepresentation of material fact, and not at all once 24 months have passed since the policy was issued (CIC §10384.17(a)-(c)). If the applicant intentionally misstated the diagnosis, the insurer may rescind within that time, after at least 30 days’ notice.
- Brenden applies for life insurance but fails to disclose his recent diagnosis of high blood pressure. The policy is issued, and he dies of a stroke six months after its date of issue. The insurer investigates and discovers the omitted medical history.
Is this concealment?
Yes. He failed to disclose a material fact.
Can the insurer rescind the contract?
Yes. Under CIC §331, concealment of a material fact, whether intentional or unintentional, entitles the insurer to rescind. He died six months after the policy’s date of issue, well within the period of no more than two years from that date after which an individual life policy must become incontestable (CIC §10113.5(a)).