Key concepts
Insurance contracts are unique because they’re based on the principle of utmost good faith (uberrima fides). That means both the insurer and the insured must act honestly, and each must tell the other in good faith the facts it knows and believes to be material, unless it has warranted them or the other party has the means of finding them out (CIC §332). If either party fails to do so, the contract may be altered, voided, or otherwise affected. The California Insurance Code (CIC) outlines several key legal concepts that shape this duty.
Representations (CIC §§ 350-361)
- Key statutes:
- §355: A representation may be altered or withdrawn before the insurance takes effect, but not afterward.
- §358: A representation is considered false if the facts do not match the assertion.
- §354: A representation can’t change (qualify) an express provision of the policy, but it may qualify an implied warranty.
- §359: If a representation is false in a material point, the injured party may rescind the contract.
Example: An applicant states they are a non-smoker when applying for life insurance. If they actually smoke, that statement is a false representation of a material fact, and the insurer may rescind the policy.
An applicant’s false answers on an application are representations, judged under these rules; material facts the applicant fails to disclose are judged under the concealment rules below. Neither is governed by §§780-784, which cover misrepresentation in selling insurance.
Misrepresentation in selling insurance (CIC §§ 780-784)
-
Who it covers:
- §780 applies to an insurer and its officers and agents, and to brokers and solicitors. Examples include an agent who exaggerates policy benefits, hides key exclusions, or describes coverage that doesn’t exist.
- §781 applies to any person. Subdivision (a) covers a known, or should-have-been-known, misrepresentation made to induce, or tending to induce, someone to buy a policy, to turn down one issued on their application for another insurer’s, or to lapse, forfeit or surrender one. Subdivision (b) covers a misleading representation or comparison of insurers or policies made to induce, or tending to induce, an insured to lapse, forfeit, change or surrender coverage, such as one used to talk an insured into replacing a policy.
-
Consequences:
- A fine of up to $25,000 (or, where the victim’s loss exceeds $10,000, up to three times the loss), up to one year in county jail, or both (§782).
- After a hearing, the commissioner may suspend the license of an agent, broker or solicitor who knowingly violates either section, for up to three years (§783).
Warranty (CIC §§ 440-449)
- Types:
- Express warranty: Written directly into the contract. Example: A fire insurance policy that expressly requires the insured to maintain an operational sprinkler system.
- Implied warranty: Not written, but assumed based on conduct or purpose. Example: A business storing explosives has an implied duty to follow safety standards.
- Consequence of breach: Violation of a material warranty or other material provision by either party entitles the other party to rescind (§447).
Concealment (CIC §§ 330-339)
- Key statutes:
- CIC §331: Either type of concealment entitles the injured party to rescind the contract.
- CIC §333: Exceptions - unless the other party asks about them, neither party has to volunteer:
- What the other party already knows.
- What the other party, using ordinary care, ought to know (and has no reason to be thought ignorant of).
- What the other party has waived the right to be told.
- Facts that prove or tend to prove a risk excluded by a warranty, if they aren’t otherwise material.
- Facts that relate to a risk the policy excepts, if they aren’t otherwise material.
Example: If the insurer already knows of an applicant’s minor past claim, or ought to know of it through ordinary care and the applicant has no reason to think it doesn’t, the applicant doesn’t have to volunteer it, unless the insurer asks (CIC §333). That an insurer could look the claim up in a database doesn’t, by itself, mean it knows or ought to know.
Materiality (CIC §334)
- Important point: Materiality is judged not by whether the omission or misstatement actually caused a loss, but by whether it could have reasonably influenced the party to whom it was owed (for an applicant’s disclosure, the insurer).
Example: If an applicant fails to disclose a history of DUI convictions, even if no claim arises from drunk driving, that information is still material to the underwriting decision.
Fraud
- When it occurs: Fraud may arise during the application process (e.g., lying about prior claims or medical history) or when filing a claim (e.g., staging an accident, inflating damages).
Consequences:
- Fraud in the application, an intentional misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact, is grounds for rescinding the contract (CIC §§331, 359).
- Fraud in a claim is handled through that claim: the insurer may deny it, and the policy’s own conditions may add consequences. It doesn’t by itself rescind the policy.
- May result in criminal penalties, including fines, restitution, and imprisonment.
- Insurance fraud is aggressively prosecuted in California, often in coordination with the CDI Fraud Division.