Needs analysis and exercise selection
Designing a resistance training program is a complex process. You do it by adjusting seven key variables:
- Needs analysis
- Exercise selection
- Training frequency
- Exercise order
- Training load and repetitions
- Volume
- Rest periods
This chapter walks through those variables using three athlete case studies:
- Scenario A: Collegiate basketball center (female) in preseason
- Scenario B: High school American football lineman (male) in off-season
- Scenario C: High school cross-country runner (male) in-season
Each athlete is healthy, cleared for participation, and has no musculoskeletal dysfunction. The programming approach for each athlete reflects sport-specific needs, training history, and performance goals.
Step 1: Needs analysis
Needs analysis is a two-stage process:
- Evaluation of the demands of the sport.
- Assessment of the individual athlete.
Evaluation of the sport
- Movement analysis: Body and limb movement patterns and the muscles involved
- Physiological analysis: Strength, power, hypertrophy, and muscular endurance demands
- Injury analysis: Common joint/muscle injury sites and the factors that contribute to them
Assessment of the athlete
- Training and injury status
- Movement screening
- Physiological profiling and performance testing
Athlete scenarios
| Scenario | Sex | Age | Sport | Position | Season |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Female | 20 | Collegiate basketball | Center | Beginning of preseason |
| B | Male | 18 | High school football | Offensive lineman | Off-season |
| C | Male | 17 | High school cross-country | Not applicable | Beginning of in-season |
Training status classification
| Resistance training status | Current program | Training age | Frequency (per week) | Training stress* | Technique experience and skill |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beginner | Not training or just began | <2 months | ≤1-2 | None or low | None or minimal |
| Intermediate | Currently training | 2-6 months | ≤2-3 | Medium | Basic |
| Advanced | Currently training | ≥1 year | ≥3-4 | High | High |
*Training stress refers to the degree of physical demand or stimulus.
Step 2: Exercise selection
Exercise selection means choosing exercises that match the needs analysis. Your exercise choices should reflect:
- Sport-specific movement patterns
- Muscles commonly used in the sport
- Goals of the training phase (e.g., hypertrophy, strength, endurance)
Application of the needs analysis
| Scenario a | Scenario b | Scenario c |
|---|---|---|
| Sport: Running, jumping, ball handling, shooting, blocking | Sport: Grabbing, pushing, repelling, blocking | Sport: Running, repetitive leg and arm movement |
| Muscles used: Hips, thighs, shoulders | Muscles used: All major muscles, especially chest, arms, back | Muscles used: Lower body, postural muscles, shoulders, arms |
| Primary goal: Strength/power | Primary goal: Hypertrophy | Primary goal: Muscular endurance |
| Training background: Trained since high school, skilled in machine & free weight, completed 4-week offseason program | Trained since high school, skilled in machine & free weight, completed 2-week in-season program | Recently began training, low experience, completed 2-week preseason program |
| Training status: Advanced | Advanced | Beginner |
| Comments: Preseason goal is strength/power using varied loads | Goal is hypertrophy due to physical demands of position | Limited preseason training and low volume |
General training priorities by sport season
| Sport season | Sport practice priority | Resistance training priority | Resistance training goal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Off-season | Low | High | Hypertrophy, strength, power |
| Preseason | Medium | Medium | Depends on sport |
| In-season | High | Low | Maintenance |
| Postseason | Variable | Variable | Not specific or recovery |
Exercise type
Core and assistance exercises
- Core exercises: Multi-joint movements that use large muscle areas; they may directly load the spine (e.g., back squat, power clean).
- Assistance exercises: Single-joint or smaller muscle group exercises; used for rehab, technique refinement, or isolating specific muscles.
Structural and power exercises
- Structural: Exercises that require postural stabilization (e.g., back squat).
- Power: Exercises performed explosively (e.g., power clean, snatch); these are a subset of structural exercises.
Movement analysis and sport-specific exercises
Use the SAID principle (Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demands) to choose exercises that mimic sport movement.
Examples of movement-related resistance training exercises
| Movement pattern | Related exercises |
|---|---|
| Ball dribbling and passing | Close-grip bench press, dumbbell bench press, triceps pushdown, reverse curl, hammer curl |
| Ball kicking | Unilateral leg press, leg extension, leg curl, single-leg squat |
| Freestyle swimming | Pull-up, lateral raise, step lunge, upright row, barbell pullover |
| Vertical jumping | Snatch, power clean, push jerk, back squat, front squat |
| Racket stroke | Flat DB fly, DB lateral raise, wrist curl, wrist extension |
| Rowing | Power clean, bent-over row, leg press, seated row, snatch pull |
| Running, sprinting | Snatch, clean, lunge, step-up, leg extension |
| Throwing, pitching | Lunge, single-leg squat, pullover, triceps extension, shoulder rotation |
Muscle balance
Programs should avoid imbalances between:
- Agonist/antagonist muscle groups (e.g., quads vs. hamstrings)
- Bilateral vs. unilateral limbs
- Upper vs. lower body
Exercises to promote recovery
- Recovery work should be performed at very low intensity (e.g., easy cycling, mobility work, light band drills).
- Low-load, low-intensity exercises can assist recovery, but more fatiguing movements (such as walking lunges) are better suited for training blocks rather than recovery.
- Typically included at the end of a session or on separate days.
Exercise technique experience
Coaches must assess whether athletes can perform exercises safely and correctly. If technique is poor, the athlete may need coaching or a regression before adding load.
Availability of resistance training equipment
Limitations in available equipment may require substitutions (e.g., front squat instead of back squat if no Olympic bars).
Application of the exercise selection guidelines
| Category | Scenario a | Scenario b | Scenario c |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core | Hang clean, snatch, push press, front squat, incline bench press, pull-up | Clean, tire flip, back squat, deadlift, bench press, shoulder press | Clean, tire flip, back squat, deadlift, bench press, shoulder press |
| Assistance | Ab crunch, seated row, stiff-leg deadlift, standing calf raise | Ab crunch, step-up, leg curl, bent-over row, shoulder shrug, biceps curl, triceps extension, seated calf raise | Ab crunch, step-up, leg curl, bent-over row, shoulder shrug, biceps curl, triceps extension, seated calf raise |
| Comments | Exercises match the movement demands of basketball (jumping/power) | Extra time allows more sport-specific lifts; hypertrophy is the focus | Extra time allows more sport-specific lifts; hypertrophy is the focus |