Achievable logoAchievable logo
CA Code and Ethics
Sign in
Sign up
Purchase
Textbook
Practice exams
Support
How it works
Exam catalog
Mountain with a flag at the peak
Textbook
Introduction
1. Basic insurance concepts and principles
2. The insurance marketplace
2.1 Introduction and learning objectives
2.2 Insurance distribution channels
2.3 Producers
2.4 Errors & omissions insurance
2.5 Insurers
2.6 Market regulation - General
2.7 Fair claims settlement practices and regulations
2.7.1 Insurance claims handling
2.7.2 Ethical mandates for insurance professionals
3. Required fraud training — CDI
Wrapping up
Achievable logoAchievable logo
2.7.2 Ethical mandates for insurance professionals
CA Code and Ethics
2. The insurance marketplace
2.7. Fair claims settlement practices and regulations

Ethical mandates for insurance professionals

7 min read
Font
Discuss
Share
Feedback

The following set of ethical mandates aligns directly with California’s Insurance Code, market conduct standards, and general professional ethics. This course material is structured to:

  1. Define the mandate (what it means).
  2. Explain its application (how agents should apply it in practice).
  3. Provide concrete examples (to make it relatable).

Fiduciary responsibility

The foundation of insurance ethics is loyalty to the customer. Agents must prioritize the client’s financial security and well-being above commissions, quotas, or company pressure.

Fiduciary responsibility (sometimes called fiduciary duty) is an obligation to act in the best interests of the person you represent, with a high level of care, loyalty, and good faith. In insurance it is chiefly an ethical standard. An agent acts for the insurer. A broker acts for the insured. California courts treat a broker’s failure to obtain the coverage the client requested as professional negligence, even when the claim is framed as a breach of fiduciary duty (Hydro-Mill Co. v. Hayward, Tilton & Rolapp Ins. Associates, 2004). Every producer still owes customers honesty and good faith, and the ethical standard is to put the client’s interests first.

In practice, this means you put the client’s interests ahead of your own and avoid any conflicts of interest that could interfere with objective advice.

Application:

  • Recommend coverage that genuinely fits the client’s needs, not the product with the highest payout.
  • Disclose any conflicts of interest.
  • Refuse to participate in deceptive sales practices, even if pressured.

Examples:

  • Advising a young family to purchase affordable term life insurance rather than steering them toward an expensive permanent policy they don’t need.
  • Recommending a lower-cost health plan with better coverage for the client, even though your commission is smaller.

When a producer acts for the client, recommending products that don’t fit the client’s needs to generate a commission breaches that fiduciary responsibility. So can failing to disclose material information about a product or misrepresenting policy terms and conditions.

Handling premium is a fiduciary duty for every licensee, whether acting for the insured or the insurer: premium or return premium a licensee receives on a policy is held in a fiduciary capacity, and diverting it to the licensee’s own use is theft (CIC §1733).

Know your job - and continue to increase your level of competence

Insurance laws, products, and market conditions change over time. Competence means mastering the fundamentals and committing to ongoing professional education so your advice stays accurate.

Application:

  • Stay up to date with California Insurance Code changes and CDI bulletins.
  • Take continuing education (CE) courses beyond the minimum required.
  • Seek mentorship, training, or industry certifications.

Examples:

  • Completing specialized training in cyber liability coverage as more small businesses seek protection.
  • Studying changes in California wildfire homeowners’ coverage requirements to advise clients accurately.

Identify the customer’s needs and recommend products and services that meet those needs

Insurance isn’t “one size fits all.” Ethical practice requires a needs analysis before you recommend any product.

Application:

  • Ask probing questions to uncover risks, goals, and financial realities.
  • Match recommendations to what the client actually needs - not what’s easiest to sell.

Examples:

  • A client says they are self-employed and concerned about missing work due to illness. The agent recommends disability income insurance rather than pushing only health coverage.
  • An older client expresses concerns about leaving assets to grandchildren. The agent discusses life insurance with estate planning benefits.

Accurately and truthfully represent products and services

Misrepresentation damages trust and is prohibited under CIC §§ 780-781; violations carry the criminal penalties in CIC §782. Ethical communication also reflects the Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith.

To sum up the Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith:

Just like a client or applicant is expected to be truthful and forthright, agents must always give complete and truthful information.

Application:

  • Explain exclusions, waiting periods, and limitations clearly.
  • Avoid exaggerating returns, guarantees, or “risk-free” claims.

Examples:

  • Telling a client that a policy has a 30-day waiting period before disability benefits begin.
  • Correcting a client who believes flood damage is covered under homeowners’ insurance (when it’s not, unless added).

Avoid jargon; use layperson’s language when possible

Insurance terms can be confusing. Ethical communication means translating technical language into plain English so clients can make informed decisions.

Application:

  • Translate terms like “deductible,” “aggregate limit,” or “indemnification” into plain English.
  • Check for understanding by asking clients to restate key points.

Examples:

  • Explaining a deductible as “the amount you pay out-of-pocket before your coverage ‘kicks in.’”
  • Saying “cash value is like a savings component inside your policy” instead of using technical investment terminology.

Stay in touch with customers and conduct periodic coverage reviews

A client’s needs change over time - marriage, children, business growth, retirement. Ethical practice includes maintaining the relationship and checking whether coverage still fits.

Application:

  • Schedule annual or semi-annual policy reviews.
  • Send reminders about major life events that may trigger coverage needs.

Examples:

  • Calling a client after they purchase a home to review homeowners and umbrella liability coverage.
  • Meeting with a client nearing retirement to discuss long-term care options.

Maintain confidentiality and protect the privacy of customer information

Agents handle sensitive financial and health information. Laws like CIC §§791-791.29, the California Financial Information Privacy Act and HIPAA require strict safeguards. The CCPA covers personal information only where those other laws don’t: it doesn’t apply to personal information collected, processed, sold or disclosed subject to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act or the California Financial Information Privacy Act (Civil Code §1798.145(e)).

Application:

  • Use secure storage (locked file cabinets, password-protected systems).
  • Limit access to client files on a “need-to-know” basis.
  • Never discuss client information casually or outside of authorized contexts.

Examples:

  • Encrypting email communications when sending policy details.
  • Refusing to share a client’s medical history with an outside vendor without written consent.

Keep informed of and obey all insurance laws and regulations

Compliance is not optional. Agents are responsible for knowing and following the California Insurance Code, Title 10 of the CCR, and CDI directives.

Application:

  • Stay updated on CE requirements.
  • Avoid unlicensed activity (e.g., selling products outside your authority).
  • Report suspected fraud as the law requires of licensed agents and brokers who are individuals (natural persons) and aren’t an insurer’s employees (CIC §1872.41(d)(1)): a suspected fraudulent application you haven’t yet placed goes directly to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days after you determine it appears fraudulent, and never anonymously. Fraud you suspect after an application has been placed goes directly to the insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU). Give the SIU and CDI any papers or evidence they ask for, and cooperate with their investigations.

Examples:

  • Reporting to CDI’s Fraud Division, before placing the application, that you suspect an applicant has submitted forged documents.
  • Refusing to sell securities-related products without the proper FINRA license.

Avoid unfair or inaccurate remarks about the competition

Healthy competition benefits consumers, but disparaging others undermines professionalism. An untrue, deceptive, or misleading statement about a competing insurer or producer’s insurance business is an unfair practice under CIC §790.03(b) when it is made or spread publicly in California and the speaker knows, or with reasonable care should know, that it is untrue, deceptive, or misleading. It may also be defamation.

Application:

  • Compete on product value and service - not rumors or false claims.
  • Correct misconceptions without speaking negatively about another agent or company.

Examples:

  • Saying, “That insurer’s policy has higher deductibles, but let’s compare the total cost,” instead of, “That company cheats its clients.”
  • Explaining your company’s claims turnaround time factually, without speculating about a competitor’s weaknesses.

Fiduciary responsibility

  • Duty to act in client’s best interest with loyalty, care, good faith; agents represent insurer, brokers represent insured
  • Failure to obtain requested coverage = professional negligence (Hydro-Mill Co. v. Hayward, Tilton & Rolapp, 2004)
  • Handling premium is always fiduciary; diverting premium/return premium to own use = theft (CIC §1733)
  • Avoid conflicts of interest; recommend what fits client needs, not highest commission

Competence and ongoing education

  • Master fundamentals, pursue CE beyond minimums
  • Track CIC changes, CDI bulletins, emerging coverage needs (e.g., cyber liability, wildfire rules)

Needs-based recommendations

  • Conduct needs analysis before recommending products
  • Match product to client’s actual risks/goals, not ease of sale

Truthful representation & plain language

  • Misrepresentation violates CIC §§780-781; criminal penalties under CIC §782
  • Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith: agents must be as truthful/forthright as expected of applicants
  • Clearly explain exclusions, waiting periods, limitations; avoid exaggerated claims
  • Use layperson’s terms (e.g., explain “deductible,” “cash value”) and confirm client understanding

Ongoing client relationship

  • Conduct periodic coverage reviews as life circumstances change (marriage, home purchase, retirement)
  • Proactively reach out after major life events

Confidentiality and privacy

  • Governed by CIC §§791-791.29, California Financial Information Privacy Act, HIPAA
  • CCPA applies only when those other laws don’t (Civil Code §1798.145(e))
  • Secure storage, limit access to “need-to-know,” never casually disclose client info

Legal compliance and fraud reporting

  • Must follow California Insurance Code, Title 10 CCR, CDI directives; avoid unlicensed activity
  • Individual agents/brokers (non-employees) must report suspected fraud (CIC §1872.41(d)(1)):
    • Pre-placement suspected fraud → CDI Fraud Division within 60 days, never anonymously
    • Post-placement suspected fraud → insurer’s SIU
  • Cooperate fully with SIU/CDI investigations and evidence requests

Fair competition

  • CIC §790.03(b): untrue/deceptive/misleading public statements about competitors are unfair practices (and possibly defamation) if speaker knew or should have known
  • Compete on value/service, correct misconceptions factually without disparaging others

Sign up for free to take 10 quiz questions on this topic

Previous
Next  | 3.1 Introduction and learning objectives
All rights reserved ©2016 - 2026 Achievable, Inc.

Ethical mandates for insurance professionals

The following set of ethical mandates aligns directly with California’s Insurance Code, market conduct standards, and general professional ethics. This course material is structured to:

  1. Define the mandate (what it means).
  2. Explain its application (how agents should apply it in practice).
  3. Provide concrete examples (to make it relatable).

Fiduciary responsibility

The foundation of insurance ethics is loyalty to the customer. Agents must prioritize the client’s financial security and well-being above commissions, quotas, or company pressure.

Fiduciary responsibility (sometimes called fiduciary duty) is an obligation to act in the best interests of the person you represent, with a high level of care, loyalty, and good faith. In insurance it is chiefly an ethical standard. An agent acts for the insurer. A broker acts for the insured. California courts treat a broker’s failure to obtain the coverage the client requested as professional negligence, even when the claim is framed as a breach of fiduciary duty (Hydro-Mill Co. v. Hayward, Tilton & Rolapp Ins. Associates, 2004). Every producer still owes customers honesty and good faith, and the ethical standard is to put the client’s interests first.

In practice, this means you put the client’s interests ahead of your own and avoid any conflicts of interest that could interfere with objective advice.

Application:

  • Recommend coverage that genuinely fits the client’s needs, not the product with the highest payout.
  • Disclose any conflicts of interest.
  • Refuse to participate in deceptive sales practices, even if pressured.

Examples:

  • Advising a young family to purchase affordable term life insurance rather than steering them toward an expensive permanent policy they don’t need.
  • Recommending a lower-cost health plan with better coverage for the client, even though your commission is smaller.

When a producer acts for the client, recommending products that don’t fit the client’s needs to generate a commission breaches that fiduciary responsibility. So can failing to disclose material information about a product or misrepresenting policy terms and conditions.

Handling premium is a fiduciary duty for every licensee, whether acting for the insured or the insurer: premium or return premium a licensee receives on a policy is held in a fiduciary capacity, and diverting it to the licensee’s own use is theft (CIC §1733).

Know your job - and continue to increase your level of competence

Insurance laws, products, and market conditions change over time. Competence means mastering the fundamentals and committing to ongoing professional education so your advice stays accurate.

Application:

  • Stay up to date with California Insurance Code changes and CDI bulletins.
  • Take continuing education (CE) courses beyond the minimum required.
  • Seek mentorship, training, or industry certifications.

Examples:

  • Completing specialized training in cyber liability coverage as more small businesses seek protection.
  • Studying changes in California wildfire homeowners’ coverage requirements to advise clients accurately.

Identify the customer’s needs and recommend products and services that meet those needs

Insurance isn’t “one size fits all.” Ethical practice requires a needs analysis before you recommend any product.

Application:

  • Ask probing questions to uncover risks, goals, and financial realities.
  • Match recommendations to what the client actually needs - not what’s easiest to sell.

Examples:

  • A client says they are self-employed and concerned about missing work due to illness. The agent recommends disability income insurance rather than pushing only health coverage.
  • An older client expresses concerns about leaving assets to grandchildren. The agent discusses life insurance with estate planning benefits.

Accurately and truthfully represent products and services

Misrepresentation damages trust and is prohibited under CIC §§ 780-781; violations carry the criminal penalties in CIC §782. Ethical communication also reflects the Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith.

To sum up the Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith:

Just like a client or applicant is expected to be truthful and forthright, agents must always give complete and truthful information.

Application:

  • Explain exclusions, waiting periods, and limitations clearly.
  • Avoid exaggerating returns, guarantees, or “risk-free” claims.

Examples:

  • Telling a client that a policy has a 30-day waiting period before disability benefits begin.
  • Correcting a client who believes flood damage is covered under homeowners’ insurance (when it’s not, unless added).

Avoid jargon; use layperson’s language when possible

Insurance terms can be confusing. Ethical communication means translating technical language into plain English so clients can make informed decisions.

Application:

  • Translate terms like “deductible,” “aggregate limit,” or “indemnification” into plain English.
  • Check for understanding by asking clients to restate key points.

Examples:

  • Explaining a deductible as “the amount you pay out-of-pocket before your coverage ‘kicks in.’”
  • Saying “cash value is like a savings component inside your policy” instead of using technical investment terminology.

Stay in touch with customers and conduct periodic coverage reviews

A client’s needs change over time - marriage, children, business growth, retirement. Ethical practice includes maintaining the relationship and checking whether coverage still fits.

Application:

  • Schedule annual or semi-annual policy reviews.
  • Send reminders about major life events that may trigger coverage needs.

Examples:

  • Calling a client after they purchase a home to review homeowners and umbrella liability coverage.
  • Meeting with a client nearing retirement to discuss long-term care options.

Maintain confidentiality and protect the privacy of customer information

Agents handle sensitive financial and health information. Laws like CIC §§791-791.29, the California Financial Information Privacy Act and HIPAA require strict safeguards. The CCPA covers personal information only where those other laws don’t: it doesn’t apply to personal information collected, processed, sold or disclosed subject to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act or the California Financial Information Privacy Act (Civil Code §1798.145(e)).

Application:

  • Use secure storage (locked file cabinets, password-protected systems).
  • Limit access to client files on a “need-to-know” basis.
  • Never discuss client information casually or outside of authorized contexts.

Examples:

  • Encrypting email communications when sending policy details.
  • Refusing to share a client’s medical history with an outside vendor without written consent.

Keep informed of and obey all insurance laws and regulations

Compliance is not optional. Agents are responsible for knowing and following the California Insurance Code, Title 10 of the CCR, and CDI directives.

Application:

  • Stay updated on CE requirements.
  • Avoid unlicensed activity (e.g., selling products outside your authority).
  • Report suspected fraud as the law requires of licensed agents and brokers who are individuals (natural persons) and aren’t an insurer’s employees (CIC §1872.41(d)(1)): a suspected fraudulent application you haven’t yet placed goes directly to CDI’s Fraud Division within 60 days after you determine it appears fraudulent, and never anonymously. Fraud you suspect after an application has been placed goes directly to the insurer’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU). Give the SIU and CDI any papers or evidence they ask for, and cooperate with their investigations.

Examples:

  • Reporting to CDI’s Fraud Division, before placing the application, that you suspect an applicant has submitted forged documents.
  • Refusing to sell securities-related products without the proper FINRA license.

Avoid unfair or inaccurate remarks about the competition

Healthy competition benefits consumers, but disparaging others undermines professionalism. An untrue, deceptive, or misleading statement about a competing insurer or producer’s insurance business is an unfair practice under CIC §790.03(b) when it is made or spread publicly in California and the speaker knows, or with reasonable care should know, that it is untrue, deceptive, or misleading. It may also be defamation.

Application:

  • Compete on product value and service - not rumors or false claims.
  • Correct misconceptions without speaking negatively about another agent or company.

Examples:

  • Saying, “That insurer’s policy has higher deductibles, but let’s compare the total cost,” instead of, “That company cheats its clients.”
  • Explaining your company’s claims turnaround time factually, without speculating about a competitor’s weaknesses.
Key points

Fiduciary responsibility

  • Duty to act in client’s best interest with loyalty, care, good faith; agents represent insurer, brokers represent insured
  • Failure to obtain requested coverage = professional negligence (Hydro-Mill Co. v. Hayward, Tilton & Rolapp, 2004)
  • Handling premium is always fiduciary; diverting premium/return premium to own use = theft (CIC §1733)
  • Avoid conflicts of interest; recommend what fits client needs, not highest commission

Competence and ongoing education

  • Master fundamentals, pursue CE beyond minimums
  • Track CIC changes, CDI bulletins, emerging coverage needs (e.g., cyber liability, wildfire rules)

Needs-based recommendations

  • Conduct needs analysis before recommending products
  • Match product to client’s actual risks/goals, not ease of sale

Truthful representation & plain language

  • Misrepresentation violates CIC §§780-781; criminal penalties under CIC §782
  • Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith: agents must be as truthful/forthright as expected of applicants
  • Clearly explain exclusions, waiting periods, limitations; avoid exaggerated claims
  • Use layperson’s terms (e.g., explain “deductible,” “cash value”) and confirm client understanding

Ongoing client relationship

  • Conduct periodic coverage reviews as life circumstances change (marriage, home purchase, retirement)
  • Proactively reach out after major life events

Confidentiality and privacy

  • Governed by CIC §§791-791.29, California Financial Information Privacy Act, HIPAA
  • CCPA applies only when those other laws don’t (Civil Code §1798.145(e))
  • Secure storage, limit access to “need-to-know,” never casually disclose client info

Legal compliance and fraud reporting

  • Must follow California Insurance Code, Title 10 CCR, CDI directives; avoid unlicensed activity
  • Individual agents/brokers (non-employees) must report suspected fraud (CIC §1872.41(d)(1)):
    • Pre-placement suspected fraud → CDI Fraud Division within 60 days, never anonymously
    • Post-placement suspected fraud → insurer’s SIU
  • Cooperate fully with SIU/CDI investigations and evidence requests

Fair competition

  • CIC §790.03(b): untrue/deceptive/misleading public statements about competitors are unfair practices (and possibly defamation) if speaker knew or should have known
  • Compete on value/service, correct misconceptions factually without disparaging others

More from Fair claims settlement practices and regulations

  • Insurance claims handling