Who may act as an insurer
California Insurance Code provides a broad definition of who may legally operate as an insurer. Under CIC §§19 and 150, the term “person” is used to describe the types of entities that may qualify as insurers. The definition is intentionally wide so it can cover the different business forms that might engage in the business of insurance. Specifically, an insurer may be:
- An individual - A single person who acts as an insurer, although this is rare in modern practice.
- A partnership - Two or more individuals who join together to form a business entity that provides insurance.
- An association - A group of people or organizations united for a common purpose, such as a mutual insurer or fraternal benefit society.
- A corporation - The most common type of insurer, formed as a legal entity separate from its owners and regulated under California law.
This broad definition allows the law to apply to the variety of organizational structures used in the insurance marketplace. No matter the form, insurers must meet California’s licensing, financial, and regulatory requirements before they can transact insurance in the state.
In California, an insurer must be admitted before it transacts insurance. A person may not transact any class of insurance business in the state without first being admitted for that class, and admission is secured by a certificate of authority from the commissioner. The State Compensation Insurance Fund, which statute authorizes, is the one insurer that needs no certificate (CIC §700(a)). Transacting insurance in willful violation of the certificate requirement is a public offense, punishable by imprisonment, a fine of up to $100,000, or both, and a court enjoins it on the commissioner’s petition (CIC §700(b)). The requirement has no exception for a customer’s agreement or for the business’s organizational form: customers who consent in writing don’t make the transaction lawful, and neither does being organized as a corporation.
Helping a non-admitted insurer is also an offense. Anyone other than a surplus line broker who acts as agent for a non-admitted insurer, or otherwise aids one to transact insurance, for an insured or applicant whose home state is California (as defined in CIC §1760.1(f)) commits a misdemeanor. So does anyone other than a surplus line broker who advertises a non-admitted insurer in California, apart from the advertising the code allows (CIC §703). Besides the penalty for the misdemeanor, the violator forfeits $500 to the state, plus $100 for each month or part of a month the violation continues. A licensee who does this also puts the license at risk: the commissioner may suspend or revoke the license of someone who has committed an act the code expressly forbids (CIC §§1668(l), 1738).
There’s also a practical risk to consumers: non-admitted insurers are not backed by California’s guaranty fund, so policyholders may have fewer protections if the insurer can’t pay claims.
Under California Insurance Code § 777.1, it is generally illegal for a company to offer “free” insurance as an incentive to get you to buy or rent property (like a car or a house) or to pay for a service.
In other words, a business can’t use a “no-cost” insurance policy as a sales inducement.
There are, however, a few specific exceptions where this is allowed:
- Newspapers - Insurance offered with a newspaper subscription.
- Credit unions - Insurance for members purchasing shares in a credit union.
- Product guarantees - Insurance that acts as a performance guarantee for goods.
- Incidental services - If the insurance costs the seller less than $1 per year for each person.
- Debts - Life or disability insurance meant to pay off a specific debt if the person dies or becomes disabled.