Auto Cancellation, Minor Drivers and the Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan
Some Wisconsin rules apply only to auto insurance: limits on why and how an auto policy may be ended, the liability of the adult who signs for a teenage driver, and the Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan, the market of last resort for drivers no insurer will voluntarily accept.
Ending an Auto Policy
Wisconsin’s general rules (s. 631.36, Wis. Stat.) set the baseline: at least 10 days’ written notice of a midterm cancellation, which after a new policy’s first 60 days must rest on nonpayment or a ground the statute allows, and at least 60 days’ notice of nonrenewal.
Reasons an insurer may never use
Section 632.35 forbids an insurer to cancel, refuse to issue or refuse to renew an automobile policy, wholly or partly, because of any person’s age, sex, residence, race, color, creed, religion, national origin, ancestry, marital status or occupation. It protects “any person,” including household drivers, and bars partial refusals, such as dropping one driver or one coverage for one of those reasons.
The rule governs who gets insured; pricing is regulated separately. An underwriter may not decline an applicant for being elderly, or nonrenew because the insured moved to another neighborhood.
Likewise, an accident while driving for work may affect the rate, terms or renewal only if the policy covers business or employment driving (s. 632.36).
Notice must point to the Plan
A notice of midterm cancellation (after a new policy’s first 60 days) or of nonrenewal is not effective unless it gives adequate instructions for applying through a risk-sharing plan, if one exists for that kind of coverage (s. 631.36 (7) (a)). For auto insurance one does: the Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan. An auto notice that leaves this out is ineffective. The exception is a cancellation or nonrenewal for nonpayment of premium, if the notice says that is the ground (s. 631.36 (8)).
Certified policies
When an insurer has certified a policy to the Department of Transportation as a driver’s proof of financial responsibility, two more rules apply under s. 344.34:
- The certified coverage does not end until at least 10 days after the insurer files a notice of cancellation or termination with the department. Notice to the insured alone is not enough.
- The insurer may not cancel the certified coverage for nonpayment of premium before 90 days from the effective date of the certification.
If the driver later obtains a different certified policy, the new certification ends the old one on its effective date.
Until the certified coverage ends this way, the insurer must pay an injured third party even if its customer let the policy lapse; the policy may then require the insured to reimburse it (s. 344.33 (7)).
Responsibility for Minor Drivers
The sponsor
A Wisconsin license application from a person under 18 must be signed and verified by a parent, a stepparent or another adult sponsor (s. 343.15 (1) (a)). That signature carries legal weight. Under s. 343.15 (2) (b), any negligence or willful misconduct of the minor while driving on the highways is imputed:
- to both parents, if both have custody and either one signed as sponsor; otherwise
- to the adult sponsor who signed.
For this rule, “custody” does not mean joint legal custody (s. 343.15 (2) (a)).
The parents or sponsor are jointly and severally liable with the minor for the damages. An injured person may collect from the parents as well as, or instead of, the teenager, up to this cap: the higher of $300,000 for all parents or sponsors to all parties from any one accident, or the limits of insurance covering the minor under the parent’s or sponsor’s policies.
Ending sponsorship
An adult who signed may file a verified written request asking the department to cancel the minor’s license, and the department must cancel it within 10 days (s. 343.15 (3)). Cancellation relieves the signer and the parents of imputed liability for the minor’s driving after the cancellation. It does not undo liability for an accident that has already happened.
Minors licensed without a sponsor
A few minors may be licensed without a sponsor, such as a minor with no living parent or one living apart from their parents who is a full-time student or self-supporting. Each must have a certificate of insurance on file for a policy meeting s. 344.33, cancelable only after notice to the department (s. 343.15 (4) (a)).
What it means for the family’s auto policy
Wisconsin auto policies cannot shut out young drivers. No policy may exclude a person using the vehicle solely because of age, if the person is old enough to drive (s. 632.32 (6) (b) 3.). And when an adult member of the household lets someone use the car, the permission makes coverage apply even if the adult broke the law by letting an unauthorized driver behind the wheel (ss. 632.32 (5) (a), 343.45 (2)).
For the producer, this changes the conversation with parents. A signing parent can be personally liable for a teen’s crash, so the liability limits on the family’s policy protect the parents’ own savings. Explain that when a teen is added.
The Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan
What it is
The Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan is an unincorporated facility, originally the state’s assigned risk plan, continued under s. 619.01 (6) (s. Ins 3.49 (2) (b), Wis. Adm. Code). Its purpose is to make automobile insurance available to people unable to obtain it in the voluntary market, by distributing those applicants equitably among insurers (s. Ins 3.49 (1)). It serves risks that are equitably entitled to coverage but cannot otherwise get it (s. 619.01 (1) (a)).
Under its rules, the Plan assigns each risk to an insurer (s. Ins 3.49 (3) (a)). A governing committee of companies administers it, and its rules, rates and forms take effect only with the prior approval of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI). Its rates must not be excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory, and the approved documents set the limits of liability an assigned insurer must assume (s. Ins 3.49 (3)).
Who must take part
Every insurer doing automobile insurance business in Wisconsin participates, and so does every agent licensed to represent those insurers for that business (s. 619.01 (1) (c) 1.). Participation carries a duty. Whenever an agent cannot place a client in the voluntary market, the agent must provide the services the Plan prescribes, including full information on its requirements and procedures (s. 619.01 (3)). Commissions on Plan business are the rates the Plan sets (s. 619.01 (4)). Placing business through the Plan does not count against the limits on exchanging business with other agents (s. Ins 6.66 (6)).
Disputes
An applicant denied coverage, or an insured whose Plan coverage is terminated, may ask the Plan’s committee in writing to review the decision, and that request stays the termination. The committee’s written decision may be appealed by petitioning OCI for a hearing within 30 days after the decision is mailed, and OCI must hold the hearing within 30 days after a complete petition (s. Ins 3.49 (3) (d)). Unlike the committee review, the petition to OCI does not stay the termination.
Lesson summary
- No insurer may cancel, refuse to issue or refuse to renew an auto policy, even partly, because of age, sex, residence, race, color, creed, religion, national origin, ancestry, marital status or occupation (s. 632.35).
- An auto cancellation or nonrenewal notice must explain how to apply to the Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan, unless it is for nonpayment and says so.
- A certified policy ends no sooner than 10 days after notice is filed with the Department of Transportation and cannot be canceled for nonpayment within 90 days of certification.
- A minor’s negligent driving is imputed to the signing parents or sponsor, who are jointly and severally liable up to the higher of $300,000 or the minor’s coverage under their policies.
- A sponsor can end liability for future driving by asking the department to cancel the minor’s license.
- The Wisconsin Automobile Insurance Plan assigns drivers who cannot find voluntary coverage to insurers; every auto insurer and its agents participate, and agents must explain how to apply.
- A request for committee review stays a Plan termination; a later petition to OCI, due within 30 days of the decision, does not.